Review upon Incorporation of a Société Anonyme (S.A.) and in Respect of Corporate Changes (Article 9 of Law No. 4548/2018)

In a previous article, we addressed the incorporation of the S.A. As has already been analysed, the incorporation procedure of an S.A. is completed through compliance with the applicable publicity formalities. Before its incorporation is completed, however, the review to which it is subject by law must necessarily take place. The same applies to other corporate changes, although these present certain differences as to their scope and procedure. The present article addresses those matters.
Introductory Remarks
One of the differences introduced by Law No. 4548/2018, as compared with the previously applicable codified Law No. 2190/1920, is the abolition of state supervision upon the incorporation of an S.A. and in respect of its other corporate changes. Admittedly, the attenuation of intensive state supervision throughout the life of the S.A. had already begun under Law No. 3604/2007, which amended codified Law No. 2190/1920. Despite the abolition of state supervision, as it had been shaped under the previous legislative regime, an administrative review is still provided for today: in some cases confined to formality (or, more accurately, completeness), and in others extending to both completeness and legality.
Legality Review
The legality review is preventive, substantive and limited in scope. In other words, the competent G.E.MI. services do not review the documents submitted for compliance with the entirety of the applicable legislation. It is provided for in Article 9 of Law No. 4548/2018, while Clarificatory Circular No. 44559/2019 is also of particular importance. The scope of that review extends to examining whether the submitted documents comply with the provisions of Law No. 4548/2018, the articles of association, and the provisions of Law No. 4635/2019 (pursuant to Article 116(2) of Law No. 4635/2019, any reference in the applicable legislation to Law No. 3419/2005 is to be understood as a reference to Law No. 4635/2019). The purpose of the legality review is to prevent the registration of acts which would be invalid (but not voidable). Acts which may be directly contrary to public order are, in any event, subject to review, notwithstanding the grammatically at least limited scope of the legality review.
Legality review is carried out in respect of those acts for which compliance with publicity formalities has constitutive effect (constitutive publicity). In addition to the incorporation of the S.A., such acts include amendments to the articles of association, corporate transformations (subject to more specific provisions of Law No. 4601/2019 or another special law), dissolution following a shareholders’ resolution or an administrative act, revival and liquidation of the company, and loss of legal personality through registration of the striking-off of the obliged entity.
Following legality review, certain acts (amendment of the articles of association, dissolution, revival) are additionally subject to approval by G.E.MI. Any approval required from other authorities is not excluded. By way of example, in the case of corporate transformations under Law No. 4601/2019, approval by the Administration is required.
Review of Formality (or, More Accurately, Completeness)
The review of formality (or, more accurately, completeness) is limited to verifying that all supporting documents required by law have been submitted. This is a formal review. It does not include examination of the content of the documents, nor review of the legality of resolutions adopted by the General Meeting or the Board of Directors. Where, upon submission of the supporting documents, a deficiency or lack of completeness/correctness is identified, the person having submitted them is called upon to supplement them. This review takes place in relation to changes in registrations, such as changes in representation and declarations for the alignment of the articles of association.
Review upon Incorporation
(a) Review of Ordinary S.A.s
The incorporation of an S.A. includes the conclusion of the corporate contract (Article 4 §2 of Law No. 4548/2018) and compliance with the publicity formalities (Articles 12 and 13 of Law No. 4548/2018 and Articles 17 and 18 of Law No. 4919/2022). Between those two stages, legality and formality (completeness) review intervenes. The incorporation procedure for ordinary S.A.s is conducted through a One-Stop Shop service (“OSS”): either by the G.E.MI. service of the chambers or by certified notaries, depending on whether or not the articles of association are executed in notarial form.
The OSS reviews the standing of the person submitting the registration application, as well as the completeness and legality of the articles of association and the documents submitted. The review is confined exclusively to matters that may entail the invalidity of the incorporation of the S.A., as will be analysed in a subsequent article. In addition, a preliminary review and approval of the corporate name and business identifier is carried out.
Provided the procedure is completed smoothly and no issues arise upon review, the OSS proceeds to register and publish the S.A., thereby completing the relevant publicity formalities. It should be noted that no prior approval decision is required.
In the event of refusal or omission to register by the OSS, even though the review has been successfully completed, an application for annulment before the Council of State may be filed. In practice, however, what usually occurs is an attempt to align with the requirements imposed by the OSS. It scarcely needs to be said that such requirements are not always reasonable, nor are they uniform across the various G.E.MI. services.
(b) Review of Special S.A.s
Certain categories of S.A.s of particular importance to the economy are subject to a more specific and stricter review. These include public-interest companies, companies incorporated by statute, and companies licensed by the Hellenic Capital Market Commission.
The incorporation of the above companies is subject to legality review by the Minister of Development and Investments (more precisely, by those acting under delegated authority from the Minister). This review is both formal and substantive. The formal legality review concerns the admissibility of the registration application (subject-matter competence, standing of the person submitting the application, required supporting documentation, availability and reservation of the corporate name and business identifier, issuance of any required operating licence, execution of the articles of association in notarial form, etc.). The substantive legality review, on the other hand, focuses on the articles of association of the S.A. under incorporation and, specifically, on verifying the existence of the organisational and operational elements required therein.
Upon completion of the review, the Minister exercises bound competence: that is, the Minister must issue an approval decision if the review has a positive outcome, or a rejection decision if deficiencies are identified. Refusal or omission by the Minister to issue an approval act, although the necessary conditions are fulfilled, is subject to annulment review by the Council of State. The relevant application for annulment may be brought by the founders, the persons participating in the subscription of the share capital, as well as third parties demonstrably having a legitimate interest in the incorporation of the company. According to the case law, a decision approving the registration of an amendment to the articles of association is likewise subject to annulment review by the Council of State, as an enforceable administrative act.
Cross-border mergers are likewise subject to review and approval by the Minister of Economy and Development (Article 9 §4 of Law No. 4548/2018).
Review in Respect of Corporate Changes
(a) Review in the case of amendment of the articles of association
Amendments to the articles of association, dissolution by General Meeting resolution and revival of ordinary S.A.s are subject to legality review by the competent G.E.MI. service. The procedure is completed by the issuance of a decision by its Head. It includes review of compliance with Laws No. 4548/2018 and No. 4919/2022, as well as with the articles of association themselves. The issuance of an approval decision constitutes a noteworthy peculiarity of this regime. Although, upon incorporation of ordinary S.A.s, a limited legality review is carried out by the OSS without the need for an approval decision, in the case of amendment of the articles of association of an S.A. the legality review is broader and the issuance of an approval decision is mandatory.
As regards amendments to the articles of association of the special companies referred to above, legality review and approval by the Minister of Development and Investments are required. Cross-border mergers are subject to the same procedure.
Refusal or omission by the Administration to issue an approval act, although the relevant conditions are satisfied, is subject to annulment review by the Council of State.
(b) Review upon registration in G.E.MI. of changes which do not constitute amendment of the articles of association
Registration in G.E.MI. of changes that do not constitute amendment of the articles of association (changes in representation, alignments of the articles of association) is subject to a formal review of the submitted documents. That regime applies both to ordinary and to special S.A.s.
Review in Respect of Registration of Resolutions of Corporate Bodies
The review carried out in the course of registration in G.E.MI. of resolutions of corporate bodies is expressly stated not to extend to grounds which would render such resolutions voidable (Article 9 §2 of Law No. 4548/2018). Accordingly, quorum, majority, and issues giving rise to voidability of the resolution, among others, are not reviewed. It follows, a contrario, that review of the invalidity and non-existence of such resolutions is permissible.
The reviews carried out at the stage of incorporation of an S.A. or in respect of corporate changes affecting it are already more relaxed than their counterparts in the past. We are gradually aligning with the rationale of reducing state interventionism. Even so, significant and necessary reviews remain in place, differentiated according to the individual case (in particular, ordinary/special S.A.s) and the significance of their respective corporate acts. What, however, is the position regarding the liability of those who incorporate an S.A.? That will be addressed in a subsequent article.
Managing Partner
Koumentakis and Associates Law Firm
Note: This article is part of a broader series of legal articles by our Law Firm on Sociétés Anonymes (SAs). In this series, we provide an article-by-article analysis of the Law on SAs (Law 4548/2018), consistently applying a business-oriented approach.