Declaration of Nullity of the Société Anonyme
(Article 11 of Law No. 4548/2018)
In a previous article, we dealt with the process of incorporating a Société Anonyme (S.A.), a process that operates within a strictly formal framework and is governed by equally strict requirements. Any deviations from this framework render the incorporation defective and, potentially, under certain conditions, void. The declaration of an S.A. as null and void is provided for specific and exhaustively listed grounds, which are examined in the present article.
Introductory Remarks
The provision regarding the nullity of the incorporation of an S.A. (Article 11) is of EU origin. To a large extent, it reproduces the corresponding provision of the previous legislative regime. A point of differentiation is the exclusion of nullity as a consequence of failure to gather the minimum required share capital, which no longer leads to nullity but is instead addressed through the dissolution of the company (Article 165).
The current legal framework governing defective incorporation regulates cases of defects that were not identified during the preventive legality control of the S.A. (Article 9). It should be noted that, in such cases, the general provisions of the Civil Code concerning defective legal acts do not apply: the incorporation of a company is not an ordinary legal transaction between contracting parties. It also concerns third parties, for whose protection the declaration of nullity takes place through a specific procedure and only for exhaustively listed grounds. Any defects not listed as grounds for nullity are cured upon the publication of the company in the General Commercial Registry (G.E.MI.).
The legislative provision on the declaration of nullity applies only after the publication of the S.A. in G.E.MI. Despite the wording referring to “nullity”, this is not strictly accurate: in reality, it constitutes a judicial dissolution.
Grounds for Nullity
The legislator provides a limited and exhaustive list of grounds for nullity of an S.A.
Specifically:
(a) Absence of a provision in the articles of association regarding the company name or the corporate purpose (Article 5 §1(a)). These elements form part of the minimum mandatory content of the articles. Among all required elements, the legislator chose to provide for nullity specifically in cases of absence of the company name (as an element of identification) and the corporate purpose.
Nullity arises only in cases of complete absence of a company name. If the name is unlawful (e.g. identical to a prior one or contrary to good morals), nullity is not established. Similarly, even a vaguely formulated corporate purpose suffices for valid incorporation.
(b) Absence of a provision in the articles regarding the amount and the manner of payment of the share capital (Article 5 §2(d)). The “manner of payment” refers to the method of subscription/coverage. Nullity arises only in cases of complete absence of reference to these elements. In cases of substantive deficiency, the company may instead be judicially dissolved under Article 165. The amount of capital may also be inferred indirectly.
(c) Failure to execute a notarial deed for the incorporation of the S.A., where required, or failure to adopt standard articles of association (Article 4 §2).
(d) The corporate purpose of the S.A. is unlawful or contrary to public policy. The actual business activity, the motives for incorporation, or any other facts outside the articles are irrelevant.
(e) Legal incapacity of all founders or of the sole founder at the time of signing the company agreement. Where there are multiple founders, the participation of at least one legally capable founder suffices for valid incorporation. This ground covers both fully incapable persons and those with limited capacity, where participation was not authorized by a court or legal guardian.
Judicial Declaration of Nullity
The declaration of nullity—more accurately, judicial dissolution—occurs through a court decision.
(a) Action for Nullity
Nullity may only be declared through a constitutive lawsuit, not by way of objection or out of court. Jurisdiction lies with the Single-Member Court of First Instance at the company’s registered seat, under ordinary procedure.
The action must be brought within a two-year limitation period from the incorporation of the company. Exceptionally, the ground relating to an unlawful or immoral purpose may be invoked even after this period, as no time limit applies (Article 11 §7).
(b) Active and Passive Standing
Any person with a legitimate interest has standing to bring the action, such as shareholders, members of the Board of Directors, and third parties (Article 11 §2). Public authorities do not have standing, as administrative supervision has been abolished.
Creditors and debtors of the company will rarely be able to establish legitimate interest, as judicial dissolution does not affect their rights or obligations.
As regards passive standing, only the S.A. itself is sued. If the defect concerns the absence of a company name, the company is identified through other elements (tax number, G.E.MI. number, etc.).
(c) Judgment
The court’s decision is constitutive. It produces res judicata not only between the parties but also in relation to shareholders. After its registration and publication in G.E.MI., it becomes enforceable against third parties as well (Article 11 §4).
The same decision appoints the company’s liquidators. Importantly, nullity does not affect the validity of the company’s obligations or claims (Article 11 §5).
The decision is registered in G.E.MI. by the Board of Directors, a person with legitimate interest, or the liquidators. The registration has a declaratory character.
Within six months from registration, third-party opposition (third-party proceedings) may be filed by persons not involved in the original proceedings, provided they demonstrate harm.
Effects of Nullity
The declaration of nullity results in the company being placed into liquidation. However, the company retains its legal personality until its final dissolution.
If shareholders have not paid their contributions to the share capital, they are obliged to do so in order to serve the purposes of liquidation (Article 11 §6).
Cure of Grounds for Nullity
The legislator provides the possibility of curing defects in order to avoid the declaration of nullity (Article 11 §3).
Cure may be achieved either:
- by amending the articles of association, or
- by converting the company into another legal form
This possibility does not apply to all grounds. Only certain grounds (absence of name, purpose, capital provisions, or unlawful purpose) may be cured.
The amendment may take place up to the submission of pleadings (Article 237 §1 Code of Civil Procedure). Once cured, the company is deemed valid retroactively.
If this deadline has passed and the defect persists, the court—upon request—must grant a period for curing the defect, unless it considers such a remedy inappropriate. This period may not exceed three months, with a possible extension of one additional month.
Within this period, it is sufficient that the amendment or conversion has been submitted to the competent authority; issuance of administrative approval is not required within the same timeframe.
During this period, interim measures (e.g. suspension of business activity) may be imposed.
If the deadline expires without remedy, the court declares the nullity of the S.A.
Final Observations
Deviations from the legal framework governing the incorporation of an S.A. cannot remain without consequences. In certain cases, they may lead to judicial dissolution of the company. Although the legislator provides mechanisms for curing defects—even at a late stage—the risk remains real and, at times, unavoidable. Therefore, the utmost diligence and attention to legal requirements during incorporation is imperative.
Managing Partner
Koumentakis and Associates Law Firm
Note: This article is part of a broader series of legal articles by our Law Firm on Sociétés Anonymes (SAs). In this series, we provide an article-by-article analysis of the Law on SAs (Law 4548/2018), consistently applying a business-oriented approach.