Acts at the Incorporation Stage of the Société Anonyme (S.A.) and Founders’ Liability
(Article 10 of Law No. 4548/2018)

In a series of previous articles, we have addressed issues associated with the incorporation of the S.A. In the course of that process, founders not infrequently enter into transactions in the name of the S.A. All such acts, however, take place prior to the incorporation of the S.A. and cannot be attributed to its legal person, which does not yet exist. The legislature quite reasonably considered it necessary to regulate the issue of liability arising from such acts. It also expressly regulated the case of defects that may arise during the incorporation stage.

Introductory Remarks

The provisions of Article 10 of Law No. 4548/2018 reproduce a corresponding provision of codified Law No. 2190/1920. This is a provision of EU origin. It delineates the liability of the founders, on the one hand, for acts and transactions carried out in the name of the S.A. under incorporation and, on the other hand, for defects attributable to them during its incorporation. The purpose of these provisions is to facilitate transactions and other acts at the company’s incorporation stage (such as leasing premises, hiring staff, purchasing equipment and raw materials, etc.). Such acts, carried out before the incorporation of the S.A., are necessary in order for its business activity to commence upon incorporation. The legislature is also concerned with protecting bona fide third parties (whether shareholders or otherwise) against losses sustained during the incorporation stage. In the absence of this special provision, attributing liability for acts carried out during the incorporation stage would be considerably more difficult. It should be noted that Article 10 does not regulate incorporation expenses, which self-evidently burden the legal person of the S.A. once incorporated.

The S.A. under Incorporation

According to the prevailing view, the incorporation stage of the S.A. commences upon execution of the articles of association (although it could also be argued that it begins at the preparatory stage). In any event, it ends upon publication thereof in G.E.MI. Publication of the S.A. in G.E.MI. has constitutive effect; prior to such publication, no legal person exists. During the period between execution of the articles of association and publication, a distinct legal formation is deemed to exist, namely the “company under incorporation”. The S.A. under incorporation is not a variation of the S.A., nor a preliminary stage thereof, nor is it legally connected with the S.A. that is to be incorporated. For that reason, acts carried out during that stage are not automatically attributed to the S.A. that will subsequently be incorporated.

Upon execution of the articles of association, a distinct legal relationship is created between the founders, having as its sole purpose the incorporation of the S.A. That relationship takes the form of a partnership. According to the prevailing, and correct, view, it constitutes a civil law partnership. However, where commercial acts are carried out, since the purpose of the entity under incorporation shifts from incorporation to the conduct of commercial acts, it is, correctly, treated as an unregistered general partnership. It is treated as such because the prescribed publicity formalities have not been observed (Article 251 §3 of Law No. 4072/2012). Once incorporation is completed, the unregistered general partnership ceases to exist. The acts carried out bind that unregistered general partnership, and its founders are personally, unlimitedly and jointly and severally liable in respect thereof. This solution is aligned with the provisions of Article 10. The S.A. ultimately incorporated may assume the liabilities arising from the legal relationships and obligations of the company under incorporation, thereby releasing the founders from any liability. Once those liabilities are assumed, any liquidation of the de facto general partnership/company under incorporation becomes unnecessary.

Where there is only one founder, whether a natural or legal person, there is no company under incorporation, nor can such a concept arise. All liabilities burden that specific person. Upon incorporation, however, the S.A. may also assume those liabilities.

Liability for Transactions at the Incorporation Stage

(a) Founders’ Liability

The founders of the S.A. are liable, unlimitedly and jointly and severally, for acts carried out during the incorporation stage. It should be noted that those persons act in the name of the S.A. under incorporation. Reference to the fact that the transactions are being conducted in the name of the S.A. under incorporation must be made in the contracts concluded with third parties. This protects the counterparties (third parties). They accept the conclusion of the contract on the relevant terms knowing that the S.A. to be incorporated has the right unilaterally to assume that legal relationship—something which is, in principle, what such counterparties seek.

Where the founders act not in the name of the S.A. under incorporation but in the name of the S.A. to be incorporated, such acts are subject to the suspensive condition of the incorporation of the S.A.; they will bind it only if it assumes them. In that case, no founders’ liability arises.

(b) Assumption of Liability by the Company

Once the S.A. has been incorporated, the Board of Directors—or the substitute body having the relevant authority—proceeds by way of a unilateral declaration of intention, even impliedly, to assume the obligations and legal relationships of the S.A. under incorporation. The obligations and legal relationships assumed must arise from a legal transaction and not from tort or unjust enrichment. It is further argued that the S.A. automatically acquires the rights arising from transactions carried out for its benefit, pursuant to the rules governing contracts in favour of third parties. Accordingly, the decision whether the S.A. is to assume the relevant right should fall within the discretion of the Board of Directors or the competent substitute body.

(c) Time Limit for Assumption of Liability

The incorporated S.A. must assume liability within three (3) months from completion of its incorporation process. According to the case law, that time limit is not a cut-off period. This means that the company may also assume obligations, legal relationships and rights of the S.A. under incorporation after expiry of that three-month period. In that case, the founders continue to be jointly and severally liable.

(d) Consequences of Assumption of Liability

From the moment the S.A. assumes liability for the legal relationships of the S.A. under incorporation, it enters into the legal relationships to which the company under incorporation had initially been a party. The founders cease to be unlimitedly and jointly and severally liable and no longer bear any liability whatsoever. The only case in which the founders may remain liable, despite the S.A.’s assumption of liability, is where a relevant agreement has been concluded with the third parties providing that the founders shall continue to be liable as guarantors or principal obligors—something more commonly encountered in lease agreements.

(e) Refusal by the Company to Assume Liability

A refusal by the incorporated S.A. to assume the legal relationships of the S.A. under incorporation may be reviewed from the perspective of abuse of rights (Article 281 of the Greek Civil Code). Such review must, however, be undertaken with caution, bearing in mind that third parties contracting with the company under incorporation knew that they were contracting with that particular legal formation.

Liability for Defects at the Incorporation Stage

Acts of the founders during the incorporation stage may, by reason of defects attributable to them, cause loss to the company and to bona fide third parties (whether shareholders or otherwise). Owing to the absence of supervision over the carrying out of such acts, liability for such losses burdens the founders. According to one view, the founders incur statutory liability (Article 10 §2), while according to another, they incur a special form of tortious liability, without excluding the possibility of grounding liability also on the general tort provisions (concurrence of legal bases).

Liability arises from specific acts and omissions. In particular, it arises from omission of a mandatory provision of the articles of association, inaccurate or incomplete information given during subscription for the capital or included in the articles of association, failure to comply with the provisions governing valuation and payment of contributions, and any declaration of invalidity of the company.

The necessary conditions for establishing founders’ liability are the existence of fault on their part (intent or negligence)—assessed by reference to the conduct of the average prudent founder—and the causation of loss to the S.A. or to a third party. The injured parties have a claim for damages against the founders, which becomes time-barred five (5) years after incorporation of the S.A. If the company is ultimately not incorporated, limitation occurs upon expiry of five years from the date on which the loss became known and, in any event, upon expiry of twenty years from the harmful event (Article 937 of the Greek Civil Code).

The founders of the S.A. do not escape liability for acts and omissions attributable to them during the stage up to its registration in G.E.MI. Those liabilities may be assumed by the S.A. to be incorporated, if it so elects. If, however, they are not assumed, they unfortunately remain personal liabilities. Further, any defects on the part of the founders may potentially give rise to additional liability. All of the above should make those involved particularly cautious. Indeed, some of their acts or omissions may even result in the invalidity of the S.A. That, however, will be addressed in a subsequent article.

Stavros Koumentakis

Managing Partner

Koumentakis and Associates Law Firm

Note: This article is part of a broader series of legal articles by our Law Firm on Sociétés Anonymes (SAs). In this series, we provide an article-by-article analysis of the Law on SAs (Law 4548/2018), consistently applying a business-oriented approach.